Now Playing

It Shoulda Been You

October 24, 25, 31

November 1,2*, 7,8,9*, 14,15, 2025

Friday and Saturday performances @ 7:30pm (NEW TIME FOR THE 2025-2026 SEASON)

*Sunday matinees @ 2pm

It Shoulda Been You is the laugh-out-loud, heart-tugging musical comedy that flips the traditional wedding story on its head—and then some.

From the moment the guests arrive, it's clear this won’t be your average “I do.” Cultures clash, exes reappear, and skeletons come dancing out of the closet in this wildly unpredictable, non-stop rollercoaster set entirely on the day of a wedding no one’s sure should even happen.

At the center of it all is Jenny Steinberg—the overlooked, underappreciated older sister and the glue holding everything together—who finds herself navigating overbearing mothers, nervous grooms, a meddling ex-boyfriend, and one massive, game-changing secret that could turn the whole day upside down.

With big laughs, unexpected twists, and a truly touching message about love, identity, and being unapologetically yourself, It Shoulda Been You is the feel-good, don’t-miss musical that’ll have you laughing through your tears—and maybe calling your own family afterward.

One wedding. Two families. And a musical you’ll never forget.